Postby mcc333 » Sat Jun 02, 2012 10:29 am
Straight,
Here's how to fail - one day just decide you're fed up and go full force to change things.
Here's how to succeed - build a case gradually that shows it is in the interest of the kids and makes sense. Your original decree is a POS. Trying to use that as your basis for doing anything will ultimately hurt you.
Since you are following a nearly 50/50 schedule, can you make any convincing arguments as to why the NJ should see the kids any less? Does she forget to help the kids with the homework? Miss appointments? Put the kids in the care of an incompetent? If the answer is no, you are not going to win an argument that the schedule should be changed or that you have the right to enforce that 2 year old POS decree. Don't go there. Can you get her to see the kids less - more play dates with friends, time with your relatives? Gradually get a shift away from 50/50. Sign the kids up for fun activities that are really developmental and good for them on her time and if she doesn't bring them you have a good case to get the 80/20.
As for the finances - make sure you keep records and start getting a document trail of what she should be paying and her denial to help support. I think the mistake you have made here is lending her credit. I'm not one for using time with the kids for financial reimbursement but in your case the only thing you had going for you in the decree was that time during the week was agreed upon between the parties. This was potential leverage which is behind you now since it's been this way for two years.
I don't see a case for you getting CS form her if she makes less than you except for one thing - you are primary. Does she live in the same school district as you such that changing her to primary would not change their school? How about the transfers - who takes the kids to the other, how long of a drive? As primary - you shouldn't do any of the transports. Again you have to gradually make an adjustment here that can be viewed as best interest of the kids - too much time in the car, etc.
Personally - I think you've waited too long to get that CS you are now looking for. At the same time, you've had 50/50 and not had to pay CS to her. That's a huge bonus considering how many guys here have had to pay the CS in your situation.
Considering all this - I think your best argument is not to go for CS but to file to amend the decree that she needs to pay for 50% of extracurriculars. You've been paying 100% and she has refused to support. Now the kids are older and there are more activities that are needed to promote good growth of your kids and you need NJ to step up. "your honor, even though I'm the primary, I have not looked for or currently ask for CS. I just need her equal contribution to these rising extracurricular costs which are vital to the kids well-being."
"I get knocked down, But I get up again,
You're never going to keep me down" - Chumbawamba